Alliance Blogs
Alan Pell Crawford
Alan Pell Crawford

Alan Pell Crawford is the author, most recently, of Twilight at Monticello: The Final Years of Thomas Jefferson, a Book of the Month Club selection and Washington Post Best Seller. A journalist and political analyst, a former U.S. Senate speechwriter and congressional press secretary, Crawford is also an accomplished public speaker and has addressed audiences throughout the United States.

False Prophets

Alan Pell Crawford

An expression of American optimism is the belief that our enemies will do themselves in and spare us the trouble. Republican intellectuals like to tell each other that the Democrats are committing political suicide, and vice versa.

Theo Anderson in In These Times says there’s not much of a future for the GOP, given that young people reject its social conservatism, while elderly voters—the only group preferring Romney to Obama in Colorado—“are, by definition, nearing the end of their lives.” This means “the most important pillar of the party’s base is gradually disappearing.”

Writing in the Los Angeles Times, Jonah Goldberg of the American Enterprise Institute thinks it’s the Democratic Party that is “increasingly ill-suited to our times.” Tax-and-spend policies cannot survive “under the weight of debt and impending austerity.”

Neither of these pundits goes so far as to predict the other side is doomed, but they come close. They have read Sean Trende’s The Lost Majority: Why the Future of Government is Up for Grabs—and Who Will Take It, which recommends against predicting major realignments in our two-party system.

The less interesting question isn’t whether the parties will adapt to the times, for in all likelihood they will; they almost always do. The more question is how engaged citizens will remake the parties. The future, after all, belongs to the activists, not to English majors looking at trend lines.


Sources: Jonah Goldberg, “Are the Dems doomed?The Los Angeles Times, June 19, 2012; Theo Anderson, “Romney 2012: It’s the end of the GOP as we know it,” In These Times, July 3, 2012.
*Photo CC courtesy of Guroadrunner.